Homeownership is a significant milestone for many individuals, and protecting this valuable asset should be a top priority. Homeowners insurance plays a crucial role in safeguarding your home and possessions against unexpected events such as natural disasters, theft, or accidents. This type of insurance provides financial protection and peace of mind, ensuring that you are not left with substantial financial burdens in the event of unforeseen circumstances.
Choosing the right homeowner's insurance policy can be overwhelming due to the multitude of options available in the market. To make an informed decision, it is essential to consider factors such as coverage options, customer service quality, and affordability when selecting an insurance provider.
To help you make an informed decision, we have compiled a list of the best homeowners insurance companies available today.
1. In our review of home insurance policies from 15 companies, the best homeowner insurance company is Amica. With a stellar reputation for exceptional customer service and comprehensive coverage options, Amica Insurance Company consistently ranks among the top choices for homeowners insurance. During our review process, we evaluate key factors for choosing a home insurance company, including standard costs, dwelling and structure coverage, identity theft protection, valuable possessions coverage, and available discounts.
PROS: CONS:
✅ Two homeowners policies available ❌ Not available in Alaska or Hawaii
✅ Policies that pay dividends available ❌ Dividend policies not available in every state
AM Best Rating Quote Access
A+ Online Estimate
Multipolicy Discount Available
✅
2. Ranked second in this ranking is insurance company State Farm. With an average monthly premium of nearly $89, State Farm is the least expensive insurer, nearly three times cheaper than the most expensive insurer. On the other hand, it offers fewer discounts than other insurance companies.
State Farm offers several options to help you enhance your policy, including identity theft coverage, home systems, service lines, energy efficiency upgrades (pay to upgrade items damaged with more energy-efficient alternatives), as well as higher coverage limits for business property and valuable personal belongings.
It's so popular, that you can buy State Farm insurance from any dealer nationwide. However, once purchased, you can use its mobile app to pay premiums and submit and track claims.
Availability: State Farm sells new policies in 47 states and Washington, D.C. According to its website, new homeowners policies are not being written in California, Massachusetts, or Rhode Island.
PROS: CONS:
✅ Least expensive insurer in our rating ❌ Not available in California, Massachusetts, or Rhode Island
✅ Large network of agents ❌ Fewer discounts offered when compared to other insurers
❌ Must purchase a policy through an agent
AM Best Rating Quote Access
A++ Online Estimate
Multipolicy Discount Available
✅
3. Ranked third on this list is Allstate Insurance Company. Allstate tends to be more expensive than most competitors' insurance and is the most expensive company. However, this can be mitigated by the amount of discounts available. Allstate home insurance discounts include Welcome and loyalty discounts, homebuyer discounts, Easy Payment Plan discounts, security equipment discounts, and Discounts for early signing. And it covers everything from purchasing an Allstate auto insurance policy to becoming a non-smoker.
PROS: CONS:
✅ Coverage available for home sharing ❌ Most expensive average rates, based on our analysis
✅ Numerous policy add-ons available ❌ Not offered in California insurers
AM Best Rating Quote Access
A+ Online Estimate
Multipolicy Discount Available
✅
4. Ranked number 4 on the list of best home insurance companies is USAA. USAA Homeowners Insurance earned four out of five stars for overall performance. The homeowner's insurance scoring formula takes into account coverage options and policy discounts, ease of filing a claim, website transparency, company financial strength, claims data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, and more.
Homeowners insurance from USAA is available to members only, limited to current and former members of the military and immediate family members. There are also military-specific protections in USAA home insurance policies, such as coverage for uniforms and military equipment for active duty members. Additionally, there is no deduction if your belongings are damaged or lost due to war.
PROS: CONS:
✅ Replacement cost coverage is standard ❌ Only available to USAA members
✅ Identity theft coverage is standard
AM Best Rating Quote Access
A++ Online Estimate
Multipolicy Discount Available
✅
State availability
USAA offers homeowners insurance in all 50 states and Washington, D.C.
5. Ranked 5th and last in the ranking of the best homeowners insurance companies is Nationwide. As part of a standard homeowner's policy, Nationwide includes coverage for both credit card fraud and building ordinances. This means that after your home has an insured loss, Nationwide can help pay to rebuild or repair your home to current building standards. There are also optional coverages for water backup and identity theft, as well as additional replacement costs for your belongings and home.
One of the 10 largest home insurance companies in the United States, Nationwide stands out by including coverage in homeowner's insurance policies that would cost you more elsewhere. Nationwide home insurance is available in most states and offers many discount opportunities.
PROS: CONS:
✅ Building ordinance and credit card coverage are standard ❌ Not as widely available as other companies in our rating
✅ Discounts for “smart home” devices, and some home renovations
AM Best Rating Quote Access
A+ Online Estimate
Multipolicy Discount Available
✅
Nationwide sells homeowners insurance in Washington, D.C., and every state except Alaska, Hawaii and Louisiana.
Conclusion: Selecting The Right Homeowners Insurance Company For Your Needs
Currently, there are many good homeowner insurance companies with suitable preferential policies. However, in the list above we only list the five best and most popular homeowner insurance companies today and are actively participating for your reference. You don't need to learn much about the best homeowners insurance company, that's a list of the 5 largest and most optimal companies that you should focus on.
Choosing the right homeowner's insurance company is a crucial decision to protect your most valuable asset, your home. While there are numerous options available, finding the one that best suits your needs requires careful consideration. Start by assessing your specific requirements, such as coverage limits, deductibles, and additional protection options like flood or earthquake insurance. Research each company's financial stability, customer satisfaction ratings, and claims handling process to ensure reliability and peace of mind in times of crisis.
Additionally, seek recommendations from friends or family members who have had positive experiences with their insurers. Remember that affordability should not compromise quality coverage; it is essential to strike a balance between cost and comprehensive protection for your home.
